Skip to content
ElderCareCosts
SOURCE DATA AUG 2026

Nursing Homes · Medicare certified

Otterbein Portage Valley

20311 Pemberville Rd · Pemberville, OH 43450 · 50 certified beds

4198337000

License number not yet on file. We only publish license numbers we can source from an official registry.

NPI 1629060058. Look this up in the CMS NPPES registry (opens in a new tab)

Are you the operator? Claim this profile. Corrections are free, always.

About Otterbein Portage Valley

In Pemberville, Ohio, Otterbein Portage Valley is listed as a nursing home. Public records list 50 beds. It is Medicare certified. Ownership records list a nonprofit operator and tie the listing to Otterbein Seniorlife. We hold 27 inspection citations for this listing, the most recent dated 15 April 2026. Public enforcement records list no fine or payment denial against it. Reported staffing works out to 3.46 nurse hours per resident per day. Every fact above comes from the public records listed in the sources section on this page. The newest source file we hold for this listing is dated August 2026.

Public record

CMS Care Compare · Source data August 2026

Certification

  • Medicare-certified (CMS Certification Number on file)

Ratings

4.0(CMS Care Compare)Source: CMS Care Compare · Updated 2026-07-01.GOV

Staffing rating

3.0

Quality-measure rating

5.0

Inspections on record

2

Cited deficiencies

25

Not yet ratedSource: CMS Care Compare · Updated 2026Q1.GOV

Staffing rating

Not published

Quality-measure rating

Not published

Inspections on record

Not published

Cited deficiencies

Not published

Not yet ratedSource: CMS Care Compare · Updated 2025Q4.GOV

Staffing rating

Not published

Quality-measure rating

Not published

Inspections on record

Not published

Cited deficiencies

Not published

4.0(CMS Care Compare)Source: CMS Care Compare · Updated 2026-06-01.GOV

Staffing rating

4.0

Quality-measure rating

5.0

Inspections on record

2

Cited deficiencies

25

4.0(CMS Care Compare)Source: CMS Care Compare · Updated 2026-08-01.GOV

Staffing rating

3.0

Quality-measure rating

5.0

Inspections on record

2

Cited deficiencies

25

Inspection history (27)

Records from January 2020 to April 2026.

  • November 28, 2022 · E

    Citation F0919

    Federal surveyors cited this nursing home on 2022-11-28 under CMS tag F0919 (CMS scope/severity E: pattern, no actual harm, potential for more than minimal harm) for Make sure that a working call system is available in each resident's bathroom and bathing area. The deficiency was recorded as corrected on 2022-12-22. Source: CMS Care Compare Health Deficiencies (as of 2026-06-01).

    View original record (opens in a new tab)Source: CMS Care Compare · Updated 2022-11-28.GOV

  • November 28, 2022 · D

    Citation F0558

    Federal surveyors cited this nursing home on 2022-11-28 under CMS tag F0558 (CMS scope/severity D: isolated, no actual harm, potential for more than minimal harm) for Reasonably accommodate the needs and preferences of each resident. The deficiency was recorded as corrected on 2022-12-22. Source: CMS Care Compare Health Deficiencies (as of 2026-06-01).

    View original record (opens in a new tab)Source: CMS Care Compare · Updated 2022-11-28.GOV

  • November 28, 2022 · D

    Citation F0684

    Federal surveyors cited this nursing home on 2022-11-28 under CMS tag F0684 (CMS scope/severity D: isolated, no actual harm, potential for more than minimal harm) for Provide appropriate treatment and care according to orders, resident’s preferences and goals. The deficiency was recorded as corrected on 2022-12-22. Source: CMS Care Compare Health Deficiencies (as of 2026-06-01).

    View original record (opens in a new tab)Source: CMS Care Compare · Updated 2022-11-28.GOV

  • November 28, 2022 · D

    Citation F0582

    Federal surveyors cited this nursing home on 2022-11-28 under CMS tag F0582 (CMS scope/severity D: isolated, no actual harm, potential for more than minimal harm) for Give residents notice of Medicaid/Medicare coverage and potential liability for services not covered. The deficiency was recorded as corrected on 2022-12-22. Source: CMS Care Compare Health Deficiencies (as of 2026-06-01).

    View original record (opens in a new tab)Source: CMS Care Compare · Updated 2022-11-28.GOV

  • November 28, 2022 · D

    Citation F0561

    Federal surveyors cited this nursing home on 2022-11-28 under CMS tag F0561 (CMS scope/severity D: isolated, no actual harm, potential for more than minimal harm) for Honor the resident's right to and the facility must promote and facilitate resident self-determination through support of resident choice. The deficiency was recorded as corrected on 2022-12-22. Source: CMS Care Compare Health Deficiencies (as of 2026-06-01).

    View original record (opens in a new tab)Source: CMS Care Compare · Updated 2022-11-28.GOV

  • January 4, 2020 · D

    Citation F0698

    Federal surveyors cited this nursing home on 2020-01-04 under CMS tag F0698 (CMS scope/severity D: isolated, no actual harm, potential for more than minimal harm) for Provide safe, appropriate dialysis care/services for a resident who requires such services. The deficiency was recorded as corrected on 2020-01-31. Source: CMS Care Compare Health Deficiencies (as of 2026-06-01).

    View original record (opens in a new tab)Source: CMS Care Compare · Updated 2020-01-04.GOV

  • January 4, 2020 · D

    Citation F0686

    Federal surveyors cited this nursing home on 2020-01-04 under CMS tag F0686 (CMS scope/severity D: isolated, no actual harm, potential for more than minimal harm) for Provide appropriate pressure ulcer care and prevent new ulcers from developing. The deficiency was recorded as corrected on 2020-01-31. Source: CMS Care Compare Health Deficiencies (as of 2026-06-01).

    View original record (opens in a new tab)Source: CMS Care Compare · Updated 2020-01-04.GOV

Penalties

Total fines on file: $0

Staffing

Latest: 3.46 nurse staffing hours per resident per day (2026Q1)

Staffing trend (5 periods)

  1. 2025Q44.41 hrs/resident/day
  2. 2026-06-014.41 hrs/resident/day
  3. 2026-07-013.46 hrs/resident/day
  4. 2026-08-013.46 hrs/resident/day
  5. 2026Q13.46 hrs/resident/day

Most recent period is lower than 2025Q4 (-0.95 hrs/resident/day). Figures are CMS-reported nurse staffing hours, not our estimate.

Ownership

Non profit

CMS Care Compare chain: Otterbein Seniorlife

Chain ID 389 · 20 facilities in chain (CMS)

  • Chain average overall rating: 3.2
  • Chain average health inspection rating: 3
  • Chain average staffing rating: 3.2
  • Chain average quality measure rating: 4.1

Chain averages are CMS-published figures for facilities sharing this Chain ID (formerly Affiliated Entity). They are not ElderCareCosts scores.

A separate ownership filing names a different organization for this listing. We are not publishing that name while the two government records disagree.

Recent changes to this listing

Watch this facility: new record changes publish to an RSS feed any feed reader can follow. No signup.

Each line is a difference between two readings of a government file. It says what the source reported, not what the provider did.

  1. Sep 1, 2026Ownership changed

    The source now records ownership as "Non profit".

    Reported by CMS nursing homes (ownership)

  2. Sep 1, 2026Ownership changed

    The source now records ownership as "Non profit - Corporation".

    Reported by CMS nursing homes (provider info)

  3. Aug 6, 2026Ownership changed

    The source now records ownership as "Non profit".

    Reported by CMS nursing homes (ownership)

  4. Jul 24, 2026Ownership changed

    The source now records ownership as "Non profit - Corporation".

    Reported by CMS nursing homes (provider info)

  5. Jul 24, 2026Ownership changed

    The source now records ownership as "Non profit".

    Reported by CMS nursing homes (ownership)

Ratings, inspections, and penalties are public records, reproduced in plain English without edits to their substance. View source records · What these measures mean.

Typical cost

Genworth CareScout Cost of Care Survey · 2025

This provider doesn't publish a specific price to us. Below is the typical OH range for the care type(s) it offers. Use it as context, not a quote.

Nursing Homes

Median · OH$9,186/mo
See full OH cost breakdownSource: Genworth CareScout Cost of Care Survey · Updated 2025

Nearby alternatives

No other listed providers in Pemberville yet.

Deciding between options? Nursing Homes Guide: Skilled Nursing & Long-Term Care

Check availability and pricing at Otterbein Portage Valley

Request info and we'll pass it directly to Otterbein Portage Valley, or call them at 4198337000 if you'd rather talk now.

Request info

Trust & methodology

Where this information came from

Each block below is one file we read, the date on that file, and the fields on this page that came from it. The date is when the source published or we retrieved it, not the day we last looked at this listing.

CMS nursing homes (provider info)as of August 2026
Chain identifier, Chain name, City, CMS Special Focus status, County, Licensed capacity, Map location, Medicare certification number, Name, Phone number, State, Street address, ZIP code
CMS nursing homes (ownership)as of July 2026
Ownership type, Parent organization
CMS enrollmentas of July 2026
NPI
CMS nursing homes (payroll-based journal staffing)as of June 2026
Staffing hours per resident day

Read how we handle every file on the data sources page.